Journal Article

Beyond Negativity: The Effects of Incivility on the Electorate

Brooks, Deborah Jordan, Geer, John G.

2007

Overview

There is much concern among pundits and political observers that incivility undermines our electoral process. Yet we have little evidence that actually documents whether incivility has such pernicious effects. This article seeks to advance our understanding of the influence of incivility on the electorate. We argue that three dimensions are central to understanding both the perceptions and effects of different types of campaign messages: tone (negative versus positive); civility (civil versus uncivil); and focus (issue versus trait-based message content). Using an experimental manipulation on a large national sample that examines these three dimensions, we find that uncivil attacks in campaigns do not appear to be as worrisome as its detractors fear. While uncivil messages in general-and uncivil trait-based messages in particular-are usually seen by the public as being less fair, less informative, and less important than both their civil negative and positive counterparts, they are no more likely to lead to detrimental effects among the public. In fact, incivility appears to have some modest positive consequences for the political engagement of the electorate. These findings are important, since attacks and counterattacks will continue to shape the American political landscape.

• Publisher: Blackwell Publishing Inc,Blackwell Publishing,Blackwell Publishing Ltd
• Subject: Advertising campaigns / Campaigns / Civility / Conflict / Discourse / Elections / Electoral campaigning / Electoral Systems / Electorate / Emotions / Manipulation / Negative campaigning / Political behavior / Political Campaigns / Political candidates / Political communication / Political elections / Political participation / Political sociology / Politics / Public life / Recall elections / Social psychology / U.S.A / Voter behavior / Voter turnout / Voters / Voting / Voting Behavior / Voting trust