Journal Article

Comparing tailored implementation strategies to improve intervention fidelity in a school-based obesity prevention program: the IMPROVE hybrid type III trial

Kwak, Lydia, Ahlgren, Jhon Álvarez, Elinder, Liselotte Schäfer, Norman, Åsa, Patterson, Emma, Annerstedt, Kristi Sidney, Andermo, Susanne, Raposo, Sara

2025

Overview

Background In Sweden, childhood overweight and obesity rates have risen significantly over the last decades, necessitating scalable interventions. The evidence-based Healthy School Start (HSS) program integrates school and family components to promote healthy habits and prevent overweight and obesity among children. The IMPROVE trial aimed to compare the effect of two tailored implementation strategy bundles (Basic and Enhanced) on fidelity to the HSS program. Methods A hybrid type III cluster-randomized trial with two parallel arms was conducted in 45 schools (cluster) in three municipalities in Stockholm Sweden from August 2021 to June 2024. The program was implemented in two consecutive cohorts over two academic school years. Fidelity was measured with an adherence score (0–4) and parent’s responsiveness (1–5) to the four intervention components (health brochure, motivational interviewing health talk, classroom module and type 2 diabetes risk test). Data were analyzed using mixed-effects linear and logistic regression models. Key findings A total of 946 parents and 655 children participated. Overall fidelity, assessed as an adherence score, was around 75%, with most components implemented as expected. The adherence score in the Basic bundle showed no significant difference compared to the Enhanced implementation strategy bundle (β = 0.01, p  = 0.95, 95% CI: –0.24, 0.25). Two of four Enhanced implementation strategies, educational outreach visits and networking between school and primary health care, did not happen mainly due to lack of interest and time among personnel. Parents born within the Nordic countries had twice the odds ( p  < 0.001, 95% CI: 1.14–3.43) of completing the motivational interviewing health talk compared to those born outside the Nordics. Discussion Enhancing the Basic implementation bundle with additional strategies did not consistently improve adherence or responsiveness. However, improvements observed over time underscore the importance of targeted support during the initial implementation year. Additional motivational actions might be needed in schools with a high proportion of children whose parents are born outside the Nordic region. These findings highlight the complex interplay between context and implementation success, emphasizing the need to adapt strategies over time to optimize their effectiveness rather than merely adding more. Moreover, the essentially null findings also point to broader methodological challenges in implementation science, particularly how to prioritize among determinants, strategy selection and tailoring. Trial registration ClinicalTrials.gov, Unique Protocol ID: NCT04984421. Registered July 30, 2021, https://register.clinicaltrials.gov/ .

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Body mass index / Child / Diabetes / Evidence-based medicine / Exercise / Families & family life / Female / Health Administration / Health Informatics / Health Policy / Health promotion / Health Promotion - methods / Health Promotion and Disease Prevention / Health Services Research / Humans / Implementation Science / Intervention / Male / Medicin/Teknik / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Medicine/Technology / Methods / Motivational Interviewing / Municipalities / Obesity / Obesity in children / Overweight / Parents / Parents & parenting / Pediatric Obesity - prevention & control / Prevention / Public Health / Quality management / School Health Services - organization & administration / Schools / Self-efficacy / Socioeconomic factors / Socioeconomic status / Standard scores / Student health services / Sweden / Teachers / Weight control