Journal Article

Smoking data quality of primary care practices in comparison with smoking data from the New Zealand Māori and Pacific abdominal aortic aneurysm screening programme: an observational study

Bartholomew, Karen, Maxwell, Anna, Crengle, Sue, Doughty, Robert N, Hill, Andrew, Chambers, Erin, Neville, Cleo, Aitken, Charlotte, Poppe, Katrina, Sandiford, Peter, Aye, Phyu Sin, Puloka, Aivi

2024

Overview

Background Quality smoking data is crucial for assessing smoking-related health risk and eligibility for interventions related to that risk. Smoking information collected in primary care practices (PCPs) is a major data source; however, little is known about the PCP smoking data quality. This project compared PCP smoking data to that collected in the Māori and Pacific Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm (AAA) screening programme. Methods A two stage review was conducted. In Stage 1, data quality was assessed by comparing the PCP smoking data recorded close to AAA screening episodes with the data collected from participants at the AAA screening session. Inter-rater reliability was analysed using Cohen’s kappa scores. In Stage 2, an audit of longitudinal smoking status was conducted, of a subset of participants potentially misclassified in Stage 1. Data were compared in three groups: current smoker (smoke at least monthly), ex-smoker (stopped > 1 month ago) and never smoker (smoked < 100 cigarettes in lifetime). Results Of the 1841 people who underwent AAA screening, 1716 (93%) had PCP smoking information. Stage 1 PCP smoking data showed 82% concordance with the AAA data (adjusted kappa 0.76). Fewer current or ex-smokers were recorded in PCP data. In the Stage 2 analysis of discordant and missing data ( N  = 313), 212 were enrolled in the 29 participating PCPs, and of these 13% were deceased and 41% had changed PCP. Of the 93 participants still enrolled in the participating PCPs, smoking status had been updated for 43%. Data on quantity, duration, or quit date of smoking were largely missing in PCP records. The AAA data of ex-smokers who were classified as never smokers in the Stage 2 PCP data ( N  = 27) showed a median smoking cessation duration of 32 years (range 0–50 years), with 85% ( N  = 23) having quit more than 15 years ago. Conclusions PCP smoking data quality compared with the AAA data is consistent with international findings. PCP data captured fewer current and ex-smokers, suggesting ongoing improvement is important. Intervention programmes based on smoking status should consider complementary mechanisms to ensure eligible individuals are not missed from programme invitation.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Abdomen / Abdominal aneurysm / Accuracy / Aged / Aorta / Aortic Aneurysm, Abdominal - diagnosis / Aortic aneurysms / Biostatistics / Cardiovascular disease / Care and treatment / Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease / Cigarette smoking / Cigarettes / Data Accuracy / Data quality / Diagnosis / Drug addiction / Electronic health records / Environmental Health / Epidemiology / Ethnicity / Female / Health aspects / Health risk assessment / Health risks / Health Services, Indigenous - statistics & numerical data / Humans / Lung cancer / Male / Maori People / Mass Screening / Medical practices / Medical records / Medical screening / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Methods / Middle Aged / Missing data / Mortality / New Zealand - epidemiology / Observational studies / Practice / Primary care / Primary Health Care / Public Health / Reliability analysis / Risk assessment / Risk factor / Risk factors / Screening / Smoking / Smoking - epidemiology / Smoking cessation / Tobacco / Ultrasonic imaging / Vaccine