Journal Article

Money Is Good, but a Friend Is Better

de L’Estoile, Benoît

2014

Overview

Based on a long-term ethnography in state-run settlement projects on former sugarcane plantations in Northeast Brazil, in this paper I question the evidence of “the economy” as a privileged framework for understanding the life situation of the poor, which is structured by precariousness and uncertainty about the future. Exploring the polysemy of Portugueseesperar(to wait, to hope, and to expect), it analyzes the plurality of orientations to the future among former sugarcane wage workers included as beneficiaries in land reform projects and their strategies to mitigate uncertainty in various configurations. If radical uncertainty lies out of human hands, relative uncertainty may be acted on by mobilizing people. While money is desirable, it has a transitory character, and the value of friends lies in their potential to help, especially in case of a crisis. Ethnography thus suggests moving beyond an “economic anthropology” that aims to analyze “other economies” and set out to explore the fields of opportunities and frames of reference that structure life situations and the local versions ofoikonomiain its original meaning of “government of the household.”

• Publisher: University of Chicago Press,University of Chicago, acting through its Press
• Subject: Agricultural land / Anthropology / Beneficiaries / Economic anthropology / Economic conditions / Economic expectations / Economic uncertainty / Ethnography / Friendship / Future / Land reform / Marxian economics / Money / Observational frames of reference / Plantations / Polysemy / Sugar cane / Sugarcane / Uncertainty