Journal Article

Accuracy of the diagnosis of pneumonia in Canadian pediatric emergency departments: A prospective cohort study

Reed, Martin, Weinstein, Michael, Bhargava, Ravi, Kirk, Valerie G., Johnson, David W., Chen, Guanmin, Curtis, Sarah, Reid, Sarah, Kellner, James D., Robinson, Joan L., van Wylick, Richard, Travassos, Gabino, Boutis, Kathy, Pusic, Martin, Bhatt, Maala, Gouin, Serge, Crotts, Jennifer, Lynch, Tim

2024

Overview

The diagnosis of pediatric pneumonia and determination of the likely pathogen are complicated as the clinical picture overlaps with other respiratory illnesses, interpretation of radiographs is subjective, and laboratory results are rarely diagnostic. This study was designed to describe the relative rates of bacterial and viral pneumonia in the pediatric Emergency Department (ED), determine the accuracy of pediatric ED physicians' ability to diagnose pneumonia and distinguish bacterial from viral etiology, and to determine clinical and laboratory predictors of bacterial pneumonia. Children 3 months to 16 years of age presenting to seven Canadian pediatric EDs before the COVID-19 pandemic with fever and cough who had a chest radiograph performed for possible pneumonia were enrolled and underwent standardized clinical investigations. An expert panel was convened and reached a Consensus Diagnosis of typical or atypical bacterial pneumonia, viral pneumonia or not pneumonia for each case. The expert panel assessed 247 cases with the Consensus Diagnosis being typical bacterial pneumonia (N = 44(18%)), atypical bacterial pneumonia (N = 18(7%)), viral pneumonia (N = 46(19%)) and no pneumonia (N = 139(56%)). Treating ED physician diagnoses were typical bacterial pneumonia (N = 126(51%)), atypical bacterial pneumonia (N = 3(1%)), viral pneumonia (N = 10(4%)) and no pneumonia (N = 108(44%)) with low agreement between a diagnosis of bacterial pneumonia by the ED physician and the panel's Consensus Diagnosis (Kappa 0.15 (95% CI 0.08, 0.21)). Cut off values that predicted bacterial pneumonia as the Consensus Diagnosis were ESR ≥ 47 mm/hour, CRP ≥ 42 mg/L and procalcitonin ≥0.85 ng/m. Age greater than 5 years and cough for 5 or more days also predict bacterial pneumonia. In this cohort, pediatric ED physicians over-diagnosed typical bacterial pneumonia and underdiagnosed viral and atypical bacterial pneumonia. Bacterial pneumonia is most likely in children over 5 years of age, with cough for 5 or more days and/or with elevated inflammatory markers.

• Publisher: Public Library of Science,Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subject: Abscesses / Accuracy / Adolescent / Age / Antibiotics / Asthma / Bacteria / Biology and Life Sciences / Blood / Canada - epidemiology / Care and treatment / Child / Child, Preschool / Children & youth / Cough / COVID-19 / COVID-19 - diagnosis / COVID-19 - epidemiology / Data collection / Datasets / Diagnosis / Emergency medical care / Emergency medical services / Emergency service / Emergency Service, Hospital / Female / Fever / Hospitals / Humans / Infant / Laboratories / Male / Medical diagnosis / Medicine and Health Sciences / Observational studies / Pandemics / Patients / Pediatrics / People and Places / Physicians / Pneumonia / Pneumonia - diagnosis / Pneumonia in children / Pneumonia, Bacterial - diagnosis / Pneumonia, Bacterial - diagnostic imaging / Pneumonia, Viral - diagnosis / Pneumonia, Viral - diagnostic imaging / Pneumonia, Viral - epidemiology / Procalcitonin / Prospective Studies / Radiographs / Radiography / Respiratory diseases / Viral infections / Viruses / Web portals