Journal Article

Moral Revolutions: The Politics of Piety in the Ottoman Empire Reimagined

Shafir, Nir

2019

Overview

Over the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries an immense body of morality literature emerged in the Ottoman Empire as part of a widespread turn to piety. This article draws upon the anthropology of Islamic revival and secularism to reassess this literature's importance and propose a new view of the history of political thought in the empire. It does so through a close analysis of a fundamental concept of Ottoman political life: “naṣīḥat, ” or “advice.” Historians have used “advice books” to counter the presumption that the Ottoman Empire declined after the sixteenth century, but in doing so they have overlooked the concept's broader meaning as “morally corrective criticism.” I analyze two competing visions of naṣīḥat at the turn of the eighteenth century to reveal how the concept was deployed to politically transform the empire by reforming its subjects’ morality. One was a campaign by the chief jurist Feyżullah Efendi to educate every Muslim in the basic tenets of Islam. The other was a wildly popular “advice book” written by the poet Nābī to his son that both explicates a new moral code and declares the empire's government and institutions illegitimate. Both transformed politics by requiring that all subjects be responsible moral, and therefore political, actors. The pietistic turn, I argue, turned domestic spaces into political battlegrounds and ultimately created new, individualistic political subjectivities. This, though, requires challenging functionalist conceptions of the relationship between religion and politics and the secularist inclination among historians to relegate morality to the private sphere.

• Publisher: Cambridge University Press
• Subject: 16th century / 17th century / 18th century / Anthropology / Bureaucrats / Campaigns / Corruption / Criticism / Dictionaries / Empires / European history / Historians / Imperialism / Islam / Literary criticism / Literature / Meaning / Morality / Political history / Political philosophy / Politics / Politics of Piety / Presumption / Private sphere / Religion / Religion & politics / Religiosity / Revolutions / Scholars / Secularism / Sermons / Society