Journal Article

Which Gridded Population Data Product Is Better? Evidences from Mainland Southeast Asia (MSEA)

You, Zhen, Li, Peng, Feng, Zhiming, Yang, Yanzhao, Xiao, Chiwei, Yin, Xu

2021

Overview

The release of global gridded population datasets, including the Gridded Population of the World (GPW), Global Human Settlement Population Grid (GHS-POP), WorldPop, and LandScan, have greatly facilitated cross-comparison for ongoing research related to anthropogenic impacts. However, little attention is paid to the consistency and discrepancy of these gridded products in the regions with rapid changes in local population, e.g., Mainland Southeast Asia (MSEA), where the countries have experienced fast population growth since the 1950s. This awkward situation is unsurprisingly aggravated because of national scarce demographics and incomplete census counts, which further limits their appropriate usage. Thus, comparative analyses of them become the priority of their better application. Here, the consistency and discrepancy of the four common global gridded population datasets were cross-compared by combing the 2015 provincial population statistics (census and yearbooks) via error-comparison based statistical methods. The results showed that: (1) the LandScan performs the best both in spatial accuracy and estimated errors, then followed by the WorldPop, GHS-POP, and GPW in MSEA. (2) Provincial differences in estimated errors indicated that the LandScan better reveals the spatial pattern of population density in Thailand and Vietnam, while the WorldPop performs slightly better in Myanmar and Laos, and both fit well in Cambodia. (3) Substantial errors among the four gridded datasets normally occur in the provincial units with larger population density (over 610 persons/km2) and a rapid population growth rate (greater than 1.54%), respectively. The new findings in MSEA indicated that future usage of these datasets should pay attention to the estimated population in the areas characterized by high population density and rapid population growth.

• Publisher: MDPI AG
• Subject: Accuracy / Anthropogenic factors / Cambodia / Census / Censuses / Climate change / Comparative analysis / Consistency / consistency and discrepancy assessment / data collection / Datasets / demographic statistics / Demographics / Demography / Errors / gridded population data / Growth rate / Human influences / Human settlements / human-environment interrelationships / Land area / Laos / Local population / Mainland Southeast Asia (MSEA) / Mountains / Myanmar / Population (statistical) / Population density / Population dynamics / population estimation / Population growth / Population statistics / Provinces / spatial data / Statistical methods / Sustainable development / Thailand / Urbanization / Vietnam